Horrible Horrible Horrible!!!!!.
Waitress making my cheesecake pancakes was licking her fingers repeatedly while she flipped my pancakes back and forth to spread the cheesecake on. Grossed out, complained, owner asked if I still wanted them!!! No, no I don't. The pancakes were put in a fridge and another waitress made new cakes. I asked the new waitress what was going to be done with the other cakes (hoping they wouldn't be served to another guest). She told me it was Tally's restaurant and he would do with his food what he wanted! I left disgusted, hyperventilating, and crying. Horrible experience. Never again. Wouldn't give it any stars if I could!!
Old Route 66 Feel.
Tally's is a great retro diner. It gives you that throwback feel. The chicken fried steak and dinner rolls were great. Sides were somewhat inconsistent, good spinach but just ok mashed potatoes and fried okra. Very friendly service!